Category: Transport Planning

Looking at Transport Planning and Design

Comment on Selwyn Station

·

Chair of Orakei Local Board gives opinion around proposed Selwyn Station

 

This morning I had spotted this photo from the Chair of Orakei Local Board (Desley Simpson) in regards to Selwyn Station:

Photo: Letter to editor published today
Source: Facebook (in public mode)

 

The proposed location around Selwyn Station is here:

Source: http://transportblog.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Selwyn-Station.jpg

 

So I sent of a list of questions yesterday to Desley Simpson seeking her comment around Selwyn Station. These were Desley’s comments to which I thank for her responses:

  • Why do you think Selwyn Station should be built

The original request came from Selwyn College during public consultation over the first Orakei Local Board Plan. In looking at the request it became obvious that in addition to providing easy access to Selwyn College such a station, with appropriate service roads and pathways, would provide a much-needed North/South link plus access to the rail public transport network for the large population in the Gowing Drive area and a number of eastern suburbs.

Currently there is a large percentage of our ward that don’t have access to rail

 

  • Who would be ‘served’ by Selwyn Station?

Suburbs south of Kepa Road and north of St Johns Road would have walking/cycling access.  Other suburbs such as St Heliers, Glendowie, Kohimaramara, Mission Bay and St Johns would have access to the rail system via feeder bus services that the Orakei Local Board have been advocating for since the first Orakei Local Board Plan.

 

  • What facilities should Selwyn Station have?
    1. Park and Ride –New Park & Ride hasn’t been part of the Orakei Local Board advocacy as yet but could possibly apply although the territory is steep and probably not particularly suitable for large-scale park n ride without a large investment in car parks.
    2. Kiss and Ride – definitely kiss and ride since the Orakei Local Board plan is for an access road to go down the Poerewa Valley from  the intersection of St Heliers Bay Rd and St Johns Rd and then bend around to go back up to Kepa Road beside Selwyn College.
    3. Cycle lockers like Papakura and Papatoetoe Stations – the OLB are already advocating for cycle lockers/racks at Orakei and Meadowbank so lockable cycling facilities at the Poerwa Station can be assumed.
    4. A bus bay like Homai, Papakura and Manurewa Stations – I haven’t viewed all the examples given but, as noted above having feeder buses servicing the local population is very much part of the Orakei Local Board advocacy so bus bays will be included.

 

  • When would you like Selwyn Station to be open and operating by (apart from “yesterday”)

The Orakei Local Board advocacy has been to get such a project included in the funding allocated to Auckland Transport in the current LTP.  At this stage it appears that funds have been allocated to carry out a full evaluation including the development of a Tamaki Drive to Glen Innes walkway/cycleway, so getting through that process is the next stage and we would like to think that this will be completed in the 2014/2015 financial year.  Indications are that construction of parts of the walkway/cycleway could be started in the 2014/2015 year.

 

  • Has Auckland Transport given any indication to you when Selwyn Station would be operating by?

It’s all a matter of funds being allocated  but the Orakei Local Board would like to see construction starting in the current term.  Hopefully this is not too optimistic.

 

  • If and when Selwyn Station is operating would you support Meadowbank Station being closed down and if so (or not) why?

We believe that the Meadowbank Station should stay open but maybe not serviced by “express” trains.  Express trains haven’t been discussed with AT but are a feature of train services overseas and our train system has to service the combined needs of “underground” and “suburban” train services so cutting out a station that services a growing community doesn’t make a lot of sense.

 

  • Has AT given any indication of numbers that would use the Selwyn Station both in the peak and off-peak

We don’t have numbers and this will be part of the evaluation process currently being undertaken.

 

  • Any comments to Transport Blog’s Tweet in regards to Selwyn Station: Horrendously expensive for low patronage

We would disagree about low patronage comment. If you consider the number of people residing in the Gowing Drive area with very poor public transport options and then add in the requirements coming out of Selwyn College and activities at the ASB Centre ( its a sporting and community facility) plus future appropriate new housing developments you don’t have to be too optimistic to see several thousand passengers a day.  Rail is expensive anyway but is the backbone of Auckland’s future public transport system and inner city suburbs are surely as entitled to be connected to the rail system as outlying suburbs are .

 

The Tweet from Transport Blog that gave rise to my last question was this one:

 

Again I thank you Desley for taking the time to reply to my questions around Selwyn Station, very much appreciated. 

 

At this point in time I continue to support the Orakei Local Board and their push for Selwyn Station. Of course like the Manukau South Rail Link, Selwyn Station will have to jump through the hoops and have a business case on it to evaluate its viability.

 

However, for now we will have to see if Selwyn will land as a project to do in the 2015-2025 Long Term project and if so when exactly. The 2015-2025 Long Term Plan starts its drafting and consultation processes later this year.

 

 

Not Particularly “Thrilled” on the Onehunga Timetable Criticisms

· 3 Comments ·

Just leave it be, bed the EMU’s in, and roll it out when Manukau is on stream

 

And so we are at day 4 of the electric trains running on the Onehunga Line – our shortest line of the Auckland rail network. After a bit of a rocky start on Monday which was expected all seems to be bedding in well on the Onehunga Line and reviews of the EMU’s quite positive.

What was not positive was the fact that the timetable did not change (so an increase in frequencies) for the Onehunga Line to reflect the EMU’s on the line.

Knowing that a new timetable is due out (all fingers crossed) in October after the Manukau Line goes on stream with the EMU’s, and knowing what goes into timetable creations from my former life in Transdev I was not particularly amused at the criticisms levelled.

On the idea “ghosting” a timetable (so creating it well advance than implementing it at the set time) it can be done but would be best effective if all lines were done at once. Knowing the Southern Line has the freighters on it and at the risk of the freighter schedules changing (for whatever reason) I would be wondering if ghosting would have worked. If someone in the know could comment on this it would be greatly appreciated – thank you 🙂

 

Anyhow the current timetable is not flash but we are meant to be rolling to all EMU’s on all lines for weekend services at the end of the year. Although they are still wiring up the Western and Southern Lines at the moment so all EMU weekend services will be interesting if those two lines are not complete by then.

At the end of the day it is a game of patience especially as we are on the final stretch.

The new timetable comes out for all lines with better frequencies later in the year. We are bedding in new EMU’s so in my opinion the existing timetable suits it rather well.

Rather than “criticising” AT I give them and Transdev the tick of a job well done this week all things considering including the teething issues on Monday.

 

Now if Auckland Transport can claw back those roll out dates for the Southern and Western Lines next year I guarantee some very happy people including me.

Our EMU’s are here and South Auckland gets the new bus network first up next year. Along with integrated fares I can say I have a 🙂 on my face for where we have got to so far. That said I also know the road ahead and I mentioned here: “Now We are Electrified, What Next?”

 

As for when I will catch my first EMU? Most likely later in the year when they ply the Manukau Line 🙂