Auckland Transport Slow to Learn Lessons on Better Transport

When will our Transport Body learn

 

The Ti Rakau Drive improvements from Auckland Transport I had come across by chance thanks to a tweet coming across my Tweetdeck. Auckland Transport are again looking at improving (car) flows at the expense of everyone else and in defiance of upcoming major transit projects in the same area.

From Auckland Transport

Ti Rakau Drive traffic flow improvements

© OpenStreetMap contributors
Auckland Transport (AT) wants to improve journey times for commuters along Ti Rakau Drive and the surrounding area. Our proposal includes changing some intersection layouts, adding peak hour bus lanes and improved pedestrian and cycling features.

Feedback is open until Sunday, 12 November 2017.

Project overview

Ti Rakau Drive has traffic congestion issues particularly during peak times.

This proposal includes bus lanes and intersection changes which will improve Ti Rakau Drive by reducing queue times and improving reliability and punctuality of bus services.

There are also pedestrian and cycling improvements making Ti Rakau Drive a safer and more pleasant journey for all users.

Main Map Ti Rakau drive traffic flow improvements

Features

There are six aspects to this project, they are:

  1. Introduce peak hour bus lanes on Ti Rakau Drive, between Wheatley Avenue and Gossamer Drive.
  2. Remove right turns at the Edgewater Drive (east) intersection with Ti Rakau Drive.
  3. Introduce two right turn traffic lanes into Gossamer Drive from Ti Rakau Drive.
  4. Extend the two left turn traffic lanes into Botany Road from Ti Rakau Drive.
  5. Extend the left turn lane into Ti Rakau Drive by changing the layout of Te Irirangi Drive at the Countdown entrance.
  6. Introduce two left turn traffic lanes into Chapel Road from Ti Rakau Drive.

Project planning

1. Peak hour bus lanes on Ti Rakau Drive

We propose to install peak hour bus lanes on Ti Rakau Drive between Wheatley Avenue and Gossamer Drive. These will operate westbound 7am-10am and eastbound 4pm-7pm. This will involve removing existing kerb-side parking during bus lane operating times. Parking would be allowed in these bus lanes outside these times.

By improving bus travel flow through this section, public transport will be faster, more reliable, and a more practical alternative for those travelling through the area.

peak hour bus lanes on ti rakau drive

old and new road layout

Proposed layout with the Westbound and Eastbound peak hour bus lanes in use.

 

2. Edgewater Drive (East) intersection

We propose to remove the right turns from Ti Rakau Drive into and out of Edgewater Drive (eastern end).
Removing the right turns will provide the space needed for the bus lane and allow safer pedestrian movement across Edgewater Drive.

Vehicles turning right onto or from Ti Rakau Drive will be able to use the intersection at the western end of Edgewater Drive (see map for detail).

edgewater drive intersection

Download the high resolution maps for Edgewater Drive (East) intersection.

3. Gossamer Drive intersection

We propose to add another right turn lane from Ti Rakau Drive (westbound) into Gossamer Drive.
This change will allow more traffic to turn right from Ti Rakau Drive and improve the efficiency of the intersection.

gossamer drive intersection

Download the high resolution maps for Gossamer Drive intersection.


4. Botany Road intersection

We propose to extend the double left turn lanes from Ti Rakau Drive (eastbound) into Botany Road, by narrowing the wide centre island.

Often only one of the left turn lanes from Ti Rakau Drive is accessible as a result of queuing through-traffic.

Extending the second left turn lane will reduce wait times, improve traffic flow on Ti Rakau Drive and improve accessibility to businesses in the area.

botany road intersection

Download the high resolution maps for Botany Road intersection.


5. Te Irirangi Drive Countdown carpark entrance

We propose to extend the length of the Te Irirangi Drive left turn slip lane into Ti Rakau Drive.

By reconstructing the layout of the Countdown carpark entrance vehicles turning left into Ti Rakau Drive would be able to enter this lane sooner, without having to queue with through-traffic. This would reduce the waiting time for left turning vehicles. This will improve the reliability of buses coming from Botany Town Centre.

te irirangi drive countdown carpark entrance

Download the high resolution maps for Te Irirangi Drive Countdown carpark entrance.


6. Chapel Road /Ti Rakau Drive intersection

We propose to add another left turn lane from Ti Rakau Drive (eastbound) into Chapel Road. A new signalised pedestrian crossing would also be installed on the slip lane to improve the safety of pedestrians.

The improvements would separate the large number of left turning and through traffic, resulting in less wait time. Traffic flow on Ti Rakau Drive would be improved allowing access to the greater eastern area.

chapel road ti rakau drive intersection

Download the high resolution maps for Chapel Road /Ti Rakau Drive intersection.


Construction of these works

We expect construction to begin in late 2018.


Have your say


Feedback on the Ti Rakau Drive traffic flow improvements is open until Sunday, 12 November 2017. We want your feedback to make sure the proposal meets the needs of locals and the different users of the area in the best possible way.

Download the brochure for Ti Rakau Drive traffic flow improvements (PDF 13MB)

Have your say on the Ti Rakau Drive traffic flow improvements

If you have difficulty completing the form, you can call us on (09) 355 3553 and our contact centre staff will fill in the feedback form with you over the phone.

Come and talk to us

  • Sunday 28 October, 11am to 3pm at Botany Town Centre (opposite Muffin Break).

After feedback closes

We will:

  • Consider all feedback and use it to help refine the route design.
  • Prepare and publish a report on the feedback received. The report will include any changes made to the proposal following the feedback period. If you provide your contact details when you give us feedback, we will notify you when the report is available.

For more information on this project

Contact Auckland Transport

 

………

Source: https://at.govt.nz/projects-roadworks/ti-rakau-drive-traffic-flow-improvements/

 

Two key lessons Auckland Transport keep forgetting right off the bat:

  1. The guise of improvement of flow will be for cars at the expense of transit, pedestrians and cyclists. Given adding general lanes triggers induced demand any savings Auckland Transport is looking for under the guise of “improving flow” will either be lost very quickly or not realised at all depending on how fast congestion builds
  2. Why are we still building slip lanes in non industrial areas. Slip lanes are dangerous to pretty much everyone especially pedestrians and cyclists in the area. Slip lanes encourage higher-speed manoeuvres by cars and the constant lack of pedestrian crossings on slip lanes make it a dangerous guessing game for pedestrians.  These kind of intersections should be handled by a signalised arrow that also allows pedestrians to cross a busy road in a safer manner (optimally the Barnes Dance would be used).

 

What is more interesting although annoying is why is Auckland Transport engaging in this now when we are looking at a change of Government? The entire stretch of Ti Rakau Drive is on a Frequent Transit Network route between Botany Metropolitan Centre and Pakuranga Town Centre (with those major bus lines continuing to Panmure Interchange). By frequent I meant busses at least every 15 minutes for most of the day seven days a week. On that alone one lane each side of Ti Rakau Drive should be a bus lane that operates from 6am until 10pm seven days a week (as all bus lanes should). That alone would help move more people between Panmure and Botany via Pakuranga more efficiently until and finally a light rail system is built from Panmure to Pakuranga to Botany, down to Manukau and out to the Airport. Sound familiar? That is because that route forms the Botany Line linking South East Auckland to the Airport, Manukau, Panmure and the City Centre.

 

Fail that we have the Congestion Free Network 2.0 that has the South Eastern BRT (bus) or LRT Line and the North Eastern BRT/LRT Line as seen below:

Congestion Free Network 2.0
Source: Greater Auckland

 

Given Auckland Transport said that these improvements wont begin until late 2018 they should hold off allowing for a change in transport direction from a possible new Government. Unless they want the entire project up-ended and started again as we might very well see with East West Link, and Mill Road being scaled back.

That said Auckland Transport should be doing a lot better as well with road upgrades even interim ones as Ti Rakau Drive would become. Dollar wise it would also be cheaper as well while also allowing productivity increases through actual more efficient movement of traffic as well.

 

 

 

 

Again Cities Skylines offers some clues for AT.

Below is how the Botany end of Ti Rakau Drive could be done. Notice bus lanes, trees and no slip lanes:

 

This would be Ti Rakau Drive towards the Pakuranga end:

 

Notice the median is still quite wide that would allow for surface or even elevated Light Rail between Pakuranga and Botany. Also no slip lanes. One thing though, bus lanes in Cities Skylines are 24/7 owing to the fact and most often well patronised routes have busses operating 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

 

Small interim improvements that would both move traffic more efficiently (including busses) and providing safer pedestrian crossing areas (no slip lanes). Given the amount of carnage on the road it begs to ask when will Auckland Transport learn from NZTA’s mistakes.

 

Feedback closes next month.

 

Advertisements

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s